City Cast Denver logo
Advertisement image

Peyton's Plate: Antonio’s Real New York Pizza

Posted on September 29, 2022   |   Updated on September 30, 2025
Peyton Garcia

Peyton Garcia

Square pepperoni pizza

Beautiful pizza bliss. (Provided by Antonio DeSousa of Antonio’s Real New York Pizza)

On my plate this week: Antonio’s Real New York Pizza. OK, hear me out: you’ll have to make a trek to get this pizza, but come on, just look at it 👆 Antonio’s is located in Estes Park, but I chose break form and highlight this out-of-town pizzeria because, well, it’s Pizza Week! And all is fair in love and pizza. Also, because it’s some of the best pie I’ve ever had in Colorado, and that’s what Pizza Week is all about right? Plus, if you were at the Colorado Pizza Pop-Up in Westminster over the weekend, you likely got to nab a slice (or three…)!



Antonio DeSousa and his family came to Colorado from Long Island, NY, back in 2006. It didn’t take him long to realize there was a gaping New York-shaped pizza hole in Colorado, and he spent nearly a decade refining the perfectbubbly, cheesy, crunchy New York-style Sicilian pizza recipe



🍕 He opened Antonio’s Real New York Pizza in 2014 and has been the (literal) talk of the town ever since.I first discovered Antonio’s during a trip to Estes Park a few years ago. Google proffered a number of run-of-mill pizzeria names to pick from, but it’s when I started asking the locals where to go that all fingers pointed the same direction: to a 6,000-square-foot, nondescript, adobe-inspired building set back from the road and roughly 1.5 miles from the main strip of shops. You might not look twice on first passing, but one bite of pie and your eyes will be opened to the beautiful, shining pizza beacon that it is 🙌


Rating:
10/10 every time.

see more:food

Share article

Hey Denver

Stay connected to City Cast Denver and get ready to join the local conversation.

Can't subscribe? Turn off your ad blocker and try again.
Advertisement image

The latest in Denver

Sponsored

Best Online Casinos for Real Money You Can Trust Today

Find the best online casinos for real money with fast payouts, big bonuses, and top games. Compare sites and start playing now.

UpVenture Logo
Keep It LocalOctober 8

Where to Find a Really Cool Costume

Skip the chain stores this Halloween. These Denver-area costume shops offer rentals, vintage finds, custom looks, and a haunted mansion t...

Tall scary figurines with long white hair and white bony faces tower over the photographer with Halloween memorabilia in the background.
Keep It LocalOctober 8

3 Locally Sourced Costume Ideas

Channel this year's buzziest shows, books, and films with finds from these Denver-area shops.

Two people assume dramatic poses to show off their Halloween costumes featuring an elegant mask, a skull mask, and lacy velvet clothing.
Denver, ExplainedOctober 1

Your Guide to Denver in October 2026

If your ideal fall Saturday includes food trucks, live music, shopping, and dogs in costumes, Tennyson Fall Fest understood the assignment.

scissors and crocheting needles sitting on top of a scarf with yarn.
Keep It LocalOctober 1

Where to Buy Beat Poet Essentials

Hip specs, used philosophy books, snail mail supplies, and Kerouac's favorite drink: Find your inner Beat poet at these four local Denver...

 A pair of glasses with brown frames rests on a brown wooden table.
Keep It LocalOctober 1

A Beat-Inspired Weekend Itinerary

Looking for a scenic getaway? Check out this guide on romanticizing your life, riding Amtrak's California Zephyr from Denver to Glenwood...

A silver train follows a track through red cliffs dotted with sagebrush in the Colorado mountains.
Denver's BestOctober 1

How to Get Those Autumnal Vibes

City Cast Denver girlies Bree Davies, Olivia Jewell Love, and Grace Zahn share their fave ways to get the autumnal vibes just right.

Two lattes sitting side-by-side.
Denver Life HacksSeptember 28

How to Navigate Denver's First PorchFest

Denver’s first PorchFest is bringing 193 acts to Baker on Oct. 3, turning porches, backyards, parking lots into stages from noon to 7 p.m...

Musicians perform for a crowd at a neighborhood PorchFest.